---
title: "The lines we won't cross when we know each member's stage"
description: "Knowing where each person stands lets you help them, or work on them. The FTC has documented what the second looks like. Here are the rules we hold ourselves to."
section: Playbooks
author: David Steel
published: 2026-11-15T14:48:27.302Z
url: https://www.sneeze.it/blog/the-lines-we-wont-cross
tags: ["borrowed-from-apps", "loyalty", "retention", "revenue"]
---

# The lines we won't cross when we know each member's stage

_Knowing where each person stands lets you help them, or work on them. The FTC has documented what the second looks like. Here are the rules we hold ourselves to._

This series started with a puzzle game. In [the first post](/blog/what-a-puzzle-game-knows-about-your-members) we looked at how a game like Royal Kingdom designs moments for each player, based on where that player is. Since then, we have borrowed the system piece by piece: a label at arrival, a path that matches where someone came from, a changed offer after a no, the first class, the first 30 days, rewards for regulars, and a pause when email goes quiet.

All of it rests on one thing. You know more about each person than you used to, and you show them something based on it. That is the useful part. It is also how a business ends up nudging people into choices they would not otherwise make.

So this last post is about the other half of the rule we set in post 1: copy the system, never the tricks.

## What the FTC has found

In September 2022, FTC staff published a report called "Bringing Dark Patterns to Light", after a public workshop the year before. Staff defined dark patterns as design practices that trick or manipulate users into choices they would not otherwise make and that may cause harm.

The report pulled together research on how well these patterns work. One study it discussed found that dark patterns doubled sign-ups for a dubious identity-theft protection service compared with a neutral design, and that the effect grew when patterns were stacked. A ticketing study found that people who were not shown fees up front spent about 20% more and were 14% more likely to complete the purchase. FTC staff said businesses should show all unavoidable fees in the upfront price.

:::stats
2x | sign-ups for a dubious service when dark patterns were used, in one study
20% | more spent when ticket fees were not shown up front
99.8% | cancellation rate when canceling was the default, in footnoted research
source: FTC Staff Report, "Bringing Dark Patterns to Light", September 2022
:::

The cancellation figure is the one we think about most. Research footnoted in the report found that when cancellation was the default, cancellations reached 99.8%, which was 63.4 points higher than when people had to cancel actively by letter. The wording of the option, and the effort it asks for, changes what people end up doing.

The FTC has since acted on fees. Its Rule on Unfair or Deceptive Fees, effective May 12, 2025, makes it unfair and deceptive to advertise a price for live-event tickets or short-term lodging without clearly and prominently showing the total price, including mandatory fees. The rule covers those two industries only. A membership business is not in its scope, but the principle is plain enough to borrow.

## The game cases

Two cases from the game world show where per-person design and real money meet. Both are stated here as what the FTC alleged and what the companies agreed to.

In December 2022, Epic Games, the maker of Fortnite, agreed to pay $520 million to settle FTC allegations: a $275 million penalty under the children's privacy law COPPA, and $245 million in refunds over what the FTC described as dark patterns and billing practices. The FTC's allegations included button layouts that led players to make unwanted purchases with a single press, and locking the accounts of customers who disputed charges.

In January 2025, the developer of Genshin Impact agreed to a $20 million penalty. The FTC alleged it misled players about the odds of loot box prizes and used layers of virtual currency that obscured what items really cost. The proposed order, which needed court approval, requires the company to disclose the odds and currency exchange rates and to let players buy directly with real money.

Membership businesses have their own currency in class credits, points and pack balances. They are useful, as long as the member can always see what a credit costs in dollars.

:::pullquote
Knowing where someone stands is how you help them. Using it against them is the line.
-- Borrowed From Apps
:::

## Our rules

We are building member stages into the tools we make, and they are not live yet. Before they are, we wanted our rules written down. They apply to anything that shows a person something based on what we know about them.

:::steps
1. Show the whole price first
Every fee a person must pay is in the first price they see. No enrollment fee that appears at checkout, no annual fee mentioned only in the agreement.
2. Make leaving as easy as joining
If someone can join online in two minutes, they can cancel or pause online too. A pause is offered as an option, not as a wall.
3. Loyalty earns more, never pays more
A renewing member never pays more than a new member would today for the same plan. Regulars get first access and recognition, not the higher price.
4. Every countdown is real
If an offer ends Friday, it ends Friday. No timers that reset, no "two spots left" when there are twelve.
5. Credits show their cost
Any pack, credit or point balance shows what it is worth in dollars, and the expiry date, wherever the member sees it.
6. Permission comes first
Tracking, retargeting and customer-list uploads happen only with consent or another lawful basis, and opt-outs are honored on every channel.
7. Could you explain it to them?
If a member asked why they saw this offer, and we told them, would they be fine with the answer? If not, we do not show it.
:::

The last rule does most of the work. A changed class time after a missed booking passes it easily ("you could not make Tuesday, so here is Thursday"). A higher renewal price because the system has learned someone never shops around does not.

:::compare "The trick" "The system"
A hidden fee at checkout. A cancel button buried three screens deep. A countdown that restarts. A loyal member quietly paying more.
---
The full price up front. Cancel and pause where you joined. Deadlines that hold. Regulars getting more for staying.
:::

## Where the series lands

The best apps treat people differently because people are different. Someone on day one needs a tutorial. Someone on week ten needs recognition. Someone who has gone quiet needs a pause, not a fifth email. A membership business has the data to do all of that, mostly unused, and the series has been about putting it to work.

:::figure wide
![A halftone illustration of a map with several winding paths across off-white paper, each ending at a studio door, with one magenta line marking a boundary none of the paths cross](/blog/media/f7f703e88a086b1a95eac8d2.jpg)
Every person gets their own path. Some lines stay the same for everyone.
:::

The house rule, once more: loyalty earns more, never pays more. And the test under it: anything you show a person because of what you know about them should be something you would be happy to explain to them.

None of this is legal advice. The FTC cases above are about games and tickets, not studios, and the rules differ by state and country. If you are changing how you price, renew or cancel, have your own lawyer look at it.

:::takeaways "The lines to draw for your business"
- Put every unavoidable fee in the first price people see.
- Let members cancel and pause the same way they joined.
- Never charge a regular more than a new member for the same plan.
- Use deadlines and scarcity only when they are true.
- Show credits and packs in dollars, with the expiry date.
- Get permission before tracking, retargeting or uploading a list.
:::

:::cta
:::

---

#### Sources

- Federal Trade Commission, Staff Report, "Bringing Dark Patterns to Light", September 2022. [ftc.gov](https://www.ftc.gov/system/files/ftc_gov/pdf/P214800%20Dark%20Patterns%20Report%209.14.2022%20-%20FINAL.pdf)
- Federal Register, 90 FR 2066, "Trade Regulation Rule on Unfair or Deceptive Fees", January 10, 2025. [govinfo.gov](https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/FR-2025-01-10/pdf/2024-30293.pdf)
- Federal Trade Commission, "Fortnite Video Game Maker Epic Games to Pay More Than Half a Billion Dollars over FTC Allegations", December 19, 2022. [ftc.gov](https://www.ftc.gov/news-events/news/press-releases/2022/12/fortnite-video-game-maker-epic-games-pay-more-half-billion-dollars-over-ftc-allegations)
- Federal Trade Commission, "Genshin Impact Game Developer Will be Banned from Selling Lootboxes to Teens Under 16 without Parental Consent, Pay a $20 Million Fine to Settle FTC Charges", January 17, 2025. [ftc.gov](https://www.ftc.gov/news-events/news/press-releases/2025/01/genshin-impact-game-developer-will-be-banned-selling-lootboxes-teens-under-16-without-parental)
