
Meta got better at the click and worse at the lead
We compared $3.1 million of Meta spend for 48 membership businesses, a year before Andromeda and a year after. The dashboard improved. The cost of a lead went up.
Notes from the work · Section
What the numbers across our accounts actually say.

We compared $3.1 million of Meta spend for 48 membership businesses, a year before Andromeda and a year after. The dashboard improved. The cost of a lead went up.

The last part of the Membership Report puts everything in the order a member lives it, with one or two things to do at each stage this quarter, using the systems you already have.

Some cancellations are not decisions at all. They are a card that expired and a text nobody sent. Here is how to catch them, and what plan length has to do with it.

The federal click-to-cancel rule was struck down, but the states kept moving. Here is a plain-English summary of where an online sign-up now means an online exit, and the questions to take to your attorney.

More Americans belong to a gym or studio than ever, and about one member in three is gone within the year. Many of them stop coming long before they stop paying.

We read the public pages of 1,104 membership businesses that sell online. Three in four say nothing about how to cancel, and 5% tell members they can cancel online.

Many members who ask to cancel want a break, not a goodbye. On the 1,104 membership websites we read, about one in four mentions a way to pause.

A new Circana survey of 3,534 US consumers puts average planned holiday spend at $779, down from $796, with 74% planning to save money. Here is what that means for a local business, and why October is the month to act.

Gyms, studios, med spas, salons and recovery chains, scored on whether an AI assistant can find them, understand them and book. The median was 46 out of 100. Not one site lets an agent book a class or appointment.
We graded every Meta ad we ran for gyms, studios, med spas and salons. The popular formats are not the cheap ones, and Meta's favorite ad is often not yours.
Book a walkthrough with David Steel. Bring last month's lead count and one location you are worried about.